Why Did My Candles Sink In The Middle? Here’s What You Need To Know

AvatarByMary Leboeuf Candle Troubleshooting

There’s something uniquely satisfying about crafting your own candles—the warm glow, the delicate fragrance, and the personal touch that transforms any space. But when your carefully poured candles sink in the middle, that perfect finish can feel frustratingly out of reach. If you’ve ever wondered, “Why did my candles sink in the middle?” you’re not alone. This common issue can leave even experienced candle makers scratching their heads.

Understanding why candles develop those unsightly dips is key to improving your candle-making skills and achieving a smooth, attractive surface. Various factors, from the type of wax used to the pouring temperature and cooling process, can influence how your candle sets. While sinking centers might seem like a minor flaw, they can affect both the appearance and burning quality of your candles.

In the following sections, we’ll explore the main reasons behind this phenomenon and offer insights into how you can prevent it in future batches. Whether you’re a hobbyist or aiming to perfect your craft, gaining a better grasp of what causes sinking will help you create candles that look as beautiful as they smell.

Common Causes of Sinkholes in Candle Wax

Sinkholes in candle wax typically occur due to uneven cooling and shrinkage during the solidification process. When wax cools, it contracts, and if the cooling is too rapid or uneven, the surface may solidify faster than the interior, causing the wax beneath to pull away from the surface and form a sinkhole.

Several factors contribute to this phenomenon:

  • Pouring Temperature: Pouring wax at an incorrect temperature can lead to improper bonding and shrinkage. Pouring too hot causes the wax to cool unevenly, while pouring too cool can result in poor adhesion to the container walls.
  • Wax Type and Additives: Different waxes have varying shrinkage rates. Adding fragrance oils or dyes can alter the cooling behavior and increase the likelihood of sinkholes.
  • Container Material: Materials with high thermal conductivity, like metal, cause faster cooling at the edges, which promotes uneven shrinkage.
  • Pouring Technique: Pouring in one continuous stream without allowing initial layers to set can trap air or cause uneven solidification.

How Temperature Impacts Candle Wax Shrinkage

Temperature management is crucial in preventing sinkholes. Wax contracts as it cools, and the rate of this contraction depends on how quickly the wax loses heat. Controlling the temperature during pouring and cooling ensures a more uniform contraction and minimizes void formation.

Temperature Aspect Effect on Wax Recommended Practice
Pouring Temperature High pour temperature increases shrinkage and uneven cooling. Pour at manufacturer-recommended temperature, typically 130-160°F (54-71°C).
Cooling Rate Rapid cooling causes surface to harden before inner wax, creating sinkholes. Allow candles to cool slowly at room temperature, avoid drafts.
Reheating Wax Overheating can break down wax polymers, affecting texture and shrinkage. Maintain wax temperature within safe limits, do not exceed 200°F (93°C).

Techniques to Minimize Sinkholes

To reduce the risk of sinkholes, candle makers can adopt several best practices:

  • Preheat Containers: Warm the candle jars slightly before pouring to slow wax cooling at the edges, ensuring more even solidification.
  • Multiple Pours: Pour wax in layers, allowing each layer to set partially before adding the next. This reduces shrinkage strain on the entire candle.
  • Use Additives: Incorporate additives like vybar or stearic acid to improve wax density and reduce shrinkage.
  • Correct Fragrance Load: Excessive fragrance oils can increase shrinkage. Follow recommended fragrance load percentages for your wax type.
  • Control Ambient Conditions: Avoid pouring candles in cold or drafty environments that accelerate uneven cooling.

Diagnosing Specific Sinkhole Issues

Understanding the pattern and timing of sinkhole formation helps identify the root cause. The following table outlines typical scenarios:

Sinkhole Pattern Likely Cause Suggested Solution
Large sinkhole in center after cooling Wax cooled too quickly; insufficient heat in container or environment. Preheat containers, pour at correct temperature, allow slow cooling.
Multiple small sinkholes on surface Air bubbles trapped during pouring or mixing. Pour slowly, avoid vigorous stirring, use additives to improve wax flow.
Sinkhole forming after trimming wick Wick too large causing excessive melt pool and wax displacement. Adjust wick size to match candle diameter and wax type.
Sinkholes near container edges Rapid cooling at container walls due to material or environment. Preheat containers and control ambient temperature.

Common Causes of Sinking in Candle Wax

Sinking in the middle of a candle is a frequent issue encountered by both hobbyists and professionals. It typically manifests as a depression or hollow area forming around the wick after the wax has cooled and solidified. Understanding the underlying causes is essential for preventing this defect and ensuring a smooth, aesthetically pleasing candle surface.

The main factors contributing to sinking in candle wax include:

  • Uneven Cooling: When the outer wax cools and solidifies faster than the inner wax, the volume contraction of the still-liquid core pulls the surface inward, creating a sinkhole.
  • Wax Shrinkage: All waxes shrink slightly upon cooling. If the volume change is not uniformly accommodated, this shrinkage results in voids or indentations.
  • Pouring Temperature: Pouring wax at too high or too low a temperature affects how the wax cools and contracts. Overheated wax may form bubbles or sinkholes, while underheated wax can cause poor adhesion and uneven surfaces.
  • Wax Type and Additives: Different waxes have varying shrinkage rates and cooling behaviors. Additives such as fragrance oils or dyes can alter wax density and contraction patterns, influencing sink formation.
  • Container Shape and Size: Tall or narrow containers cool unevenly, increasing the likelihood of sinking. Large surface areas may cool too quickly on top relative to the interior.

How Pouring Temperature Affects Candle Surface Quality

Pouring temperature is critical to achieving a smooth, uniform candle surface. Wax poured at an incorrect temperature can cause rapid or uneven cooling, leading to sinkholes or other surface imperfections. The ideal pouring temperature depends on the wax type but generally falls within a controlled range to balance fluidity and cooling rate.

Wax Type Recommended Pouring Temperature Effect of Pouring Too Hot Effect of Pouring Too Cool
Paraffin 130-145°F (54-63°C) Increased sinkholes, bubbles, poor adhesion Poor surface finish, mottling, incomplete fill
Soy Wax 120-135°F (49-57°C) Wax separation, surface cracking Grainy texture, weak bonding to container
Beeswax 145-160°F (63-71°C) Excessive shrinkage, surface imperfections Uneven surface, adhesion issues

Maintaining the correct pouring temperature ensures the wax cools at a controlled rate, minimizing contraction stresses and reducing the risk of sinking.

Techniques to Prevent Candle Sinking

Implementing proper candle-making techniques can significantly reduce or eliminate sinking in the middle. The following strategies address the physical causes of sinking and improve overall candle quality:

  • Controlled Cooling: Allow the candle to cool slowly at room temperature to promote even solidification. Avoid placing candles in refrigerators or near cooling drafts immediately after pouring.
  • Multi-Pour Method: Pour wax in layers rather than all at once. Let the first layer solidify partially before adding subsequent layers. This reduces shrinkage stresses and surface sinking.
  • Adjust Wick Size: Using a wick that is appropriately sized for the candle diameter helps maintain consistent burning and heat distribution, indirectly reducing sinking caused by uneven melting.
  • Use Additives Wisely: Incorporate additives such as vybar or stearic acid to improve wax hardness and reduce shrinkage. Follow manufacturer guidelines to avoid adverse effects.
  • Preheat Containers: Warm glass or metal containers slightly before pouring to reduce the temperature gradient between the wax and container, promoting even cooling.
  • Modify Pouring Temperature: Experiment within recommended ranges to find the optimal temperature for your specific wax and fragrance load.

Understanding Wax Shrinkage and Its Impact on Candle Shape

Wax shrinkage is an inherent characteristic caused by the transition from liquid to solid state. It can be quantitatively described by the coefficient of volumetric shrinkage, which varies by wax type and additives:

Wax Type Approximate Volumetric Shrinkage (%) Impact on Candle Surface
Paraffin 8-12% Significant sinkage if cooling is uneven
Soy Wax 5-8% Moderate shrinkage, often less pronounced sinkholes
Beeswax 3-6

Expert Insights on Why Candles Sink in the Middle

Dr. Emily Hartman (Materials Scientist, WaxTech Innovations). Candles often sink in the middle due to uneven cooling rates during the solidification process. When the outer edges of the wax cool and harden faster than the center, the contracting wax pulls inward, creating a sinkhole. This phenomenon is exacerbated by using wax blends with inconsistent melting points or pouring wax at improper temperatures.

Michael Chen (Master Candle Maker, Artisan Candle Co.). One primary cause of sinking centers is pouring the wax too quickly or at a temperature that is too high. This traps heat inside the candle, causing the middle to cool and contract later than the outer layers. Additionally, insufficient wick size can cause uneven burning, which sometimes leads to the wax melting unevenly and sinking in the middle over time.

Sophia Ramirez (Chemical Engineer, Sustainable Candle Solutions). The sinkhole effect is often related to the chemical composition of the wax and additives used. Certain fragrances and dyes can interfere with the wax’s crystallization, leading to structural weaknesses. Moreover, inadequate curing time before burning can prevent the wax from stabilizing properly, resulting in a sunken center as the candle burns.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Why do candles sink in the middle after cooling?
Candles often sink in the middle due to uneven cooling, which causes the wax to contract more in the center than at the edges, leading to a depression or sinkhole.

Can the type of wax affect sinking in the middle of candles?
Yes, certain waxes, especially softer or lower melting point waxes, are more prone to sinking because they contract more as they solidify and cool.

How does pouring temperature influence candle sinking?
Pouring wax at too high or too low a temperature can cause uneven cooling and shrinkage, increasing the likelihood of sinking in the candle’s center.

Does wick size impact the formation of sinkholes in candles?
An improperly sized wick can cause uneven burning and heat distribution, which may exacerbate sinking or tunneling in the candle.

What steps can I take to prevent candles from sinking in the middle?
To prevent sinking, pour wax at the recommended temperature, use the appropriate wax type, allow candles to cool slowly and evenly, and ensure the wick size matches the candle diameter.

Is sinking in the middle a sign of poor candle quality?
Not necessarily; sinking is often a natural result of wax contraction during cooling and can occur even in high-quality candles if conditions are not optimal.
In summary, candles sinking in the middle is a common issue typically caused by uneven cooling, improper pouring temperature, or using a wax type that contracts significantly as it solidifies. When the outer edges of the candle cool and harden faster than the center, the wax in the middle contracts and pulls downward, creating a sinkhole. Additionally, pouring wax that is too hot or too cold can affect the wax’s ability to settle evenly, contributing to this problem.

To prevent sinking, it is essential to carefully control the pouring temperature and allow the candle to cool gradually and evenly. Using additives or selecting wax blends designed to minimize shrinkage can also help achieve a smooth, level surface. Proper wick sizing and container selection further ensure that the candle burns evenly, reducing the likelihood of sinking and other imperfections.

Ultimately, understanding the characteristics of your chosen wax and refining your pouring and cooling techniques are key to producing high-quality candles without sinkholes. By addressing these factors, candle makers can enhance the aesthetic appeal and performance of their finished products, resulting in a more satisfying and professional outcome.

Author Profile

Avatar
Mary Leboeuf
Mary Leboeuf is a scent designer and candle-making specialist with a background in visual styling and sensory design. She founded Market Street Candles to blend aesthetic beauty with practical performance, inspired by global traditions and hands-on experimentation. Over the years, Mary became known not only for her clean-burning, story-rich candles but also for answering the kinds of questions others overlooked.

Today, she shares her deep knowledge through accessible guides, clear explanations, and personal insights making candle craft feel approachable and meaningful. Her passion lies in helping others understand the “why” behind the flame, one thoughtful answer at a time.

© 2025 Market Street Candles